Head to head
Mahindra Thar vs Maruti Suzuki Jimny: what owners and experts say
Based on 255 statements from 23 owner and expert reviews
Reviewers rate the Jimny better for ride comfort, fit & finish and off-road capability, and there is no area where the Thar is clearly ahead. On handling, boot space and driving position there is little to separate them. The Thar starts at ₹10.32 lakh and the Jimny at ₹12.54 lakh ex-showroom, so the Thar is about ₹2.22 lakh cheaper to start with.
| Fact | Thar | Jimny |
|---|---|---|
| Ex-showroom price | ₹10.32 lakh to ₹17.79 lakh | ₹12.54 lakh to ₹14.67 lakh |
| Fuel | Diesel, Petrol | Petrol |
| Gearbox | Manual, Automatic | Manual, Automatic |
| Seating | 4 | 4 |
| Reviews we read | 10 | 13 |
Where the Jimny does better
Ride comfort
Jimny: Strongly positiveThar: Generally negative
Jimny: “A highlight on the Jimny is ride comfort — low speed ride is nice and absorbent, and even at higher speeds it feels quite planted. Of course the fact that it sits relatively low to the ground makes a big difference here.”
Fit & finish
Jimny: Mixed reviewsThar: Generally negative
Thar: “After about 10,000 km, the seats and roof lining become loose — especially after a ~1,000 km rough mountain-road trip to Spiti; had them retightened at the service center.”
Off-road capability
Jimny: Strongly positiveThar: Generally positive
Jimny: “In a low speed setting as this it hasn't really posed a problem at all over everything we've put it through -- the torque multiplication of course off the gearbox helps, and it just feels very comfortable, very light on its feet.”
Thar: “On the very same path the Thar feels different -- the line in isn't identical, but the tire also does things differently... the Thar's wider track, and I guess the weight, sort of give it a firmer form of footing.”
Area by area
Every area where reviewers said enough about at least one of the two cars. “Too few reviews” means we won’t guess.
| Area | Thar | Jimny |
|---|---|---|
| Ride comfort | Generally negative | Strongly positive |
| Fit & finish | Generally negative | Mixed reviews |
| Off-road capability | Generally positive | Strongly positive |
| Handling | Generally negative | Strongly negative |
| Boot space | Generally negative | Mixed reviews |
| Driving position | Generally positive | Generally positive |
| Rear seat space | Generally negative | Strongly negative |
| Seat comfort | Generally positive | Generally positive |
| Braking | Mixed reviews | Too few reviews |
| City drivability | Too few reviews | Strongly positive |
| City mileage | Too few reviews | Mixed reviews |
| Crash safety | Strongly positive | Too few reviews |
| Electrical reliability | Strongly negative | Too few reviews |
| Engine refinement | Strongly positive | Too few reviews |
| Front seat space | Too few reviews | Generally positive |
| Ground clearance | Too few reviews | Strongly positive |
| Headlight quality | Too few reviews | Generally positive |
| Highway mileage | Too few reviews | Generally negative |
| Highway stability | Strongly positive | Too few reviews |
| Long-term build quality | Generally positive | Too few reviews |
| Tight-space driving | Too few reviews | Strongly positive |
| Touchscreen responsiveness | Too few reviews | Strongly positive |
| Turning radius | Too few reviews | Strongly negative |
| Tyre quality | Generally negative | Too few reviews |
So, Thar or Jimny?
If ride comfort and fit & finish matter to you, the Jimny is the safer bet. Otherwise it comes down to price, looks and the test drive.
Reviews only tell you how a car has worked out for other people. Whether it suits you depends on your roads, your family and your budget. Answer 11 quick questions and we’ll match you to the cars with the strongest evidence for how you actually drive.
Read the full reviews
Thar vs Jimny FAQs
Which is better, the Thar or the Jimny?
Reviewers rate the Jimny better for ride comfort, fit & finish and off-road capability, and there is no area where the Thar is clearly ahead. If ride comfort and fit & finish matter to you, the Jimny is the safer bet. Otherwise it comes down to price, looks and the test drive.
Which is cheaper, the Thar or the Jimny?
The Thar starts at ₹10.32 lakh and the Jimny at ₹12.54 lakh ex-showroom, so the Thar is about ₹2.22 lakh cheaper to start with.
How did CarDhoondo compare the Thar and Jimny?
We went through 23 owner and expert video reviews of the two cars, tagged every statement by topic, such as mileage or rear seat space, and scored how positive it was. Nobody paid for this comparison and it is not sponsored.
How this page is made: we collect what real owners and expert reviewers say in published video reviews, tag each statement by topic and score how positive or negative it is. A car only counts as doing better in an area when the gap between the two verdicts is clear. Nothing here is paid for by manufacturers or dealers. Prices come from CarDekho and can change, so confirm with a dealer.